{
  "schema": "la4kb-breaks-v1-draft",
  "note": "Curated public list. Only CONFIRMED or REPAIRED entries appear here. Historical entries filled only from repo/scoreboard data; unknown fields are null with a todo.",
  "generated_at": "2026-10-19T23:30:00Z",
  "entries": [
    {
      "id": "D9",
      "api_version": "V1",
      "state": "REPAIRED",
      "title": "Finite INSTANCE evidence yielded SUPPORTED for a UNIVERSAL claim",
      "classification": "PUBLIC_ADAPTER_DEFECT (kernel exonerated)",
      "broken_at_utc": "2026-09-23T19:34:00Z",
      "reporter": null,
      "source": null,
      "todo": ["reporter and source (person / LLM / fuzzer) not recorded in repo or scoreboard"],
      "method": "Claim quantifier UNIVERSAL with a single positive evidence item evidence_nature INSTANCE and operator RANGE. The public adapter (blackbox/runner.py) mapped RANGE evidence to EvidenceConstraint, discarding INSTANCE semantics. Reproduced 4/4 on the public endpoint.",
      "repro": {"job_ids": ["chk-48be69cc-e19d-46cf-ac83-74d0502ac73b","chk-7efcd03d-2bf6-40ca-aab9-d99d4f5aeb58","chk-230155bf-3b6d-4526-a5fd-731124ac96c7","chk-950b3b2f-96e8-4e9c-9f7d-dafaa9862bfa"], "observed": "SUPPORTED", "expected": "INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE", "evidence_ref": "blackbox/defects/D9_UNIVERSAL_INSTANCE_REPRO/manifest.json"},
      "repair": {
        "repaired_at_utc": "2026-09-23T20:18:28Z",
        "fix_commit": "b4eea47910deb2d15078e3b2300c4623f5c8a37c",
        "fix_summary": "Enforce evidence_nature gating in the public adapter.",
        "regression_tests": ["tests/test_best2_contract_regression.py (per PROJECT_HISTORY.md)"],
        "released_in": "V1 public service (adapter fix; engine 6f6aff4 unchanged)",
        "post_fix_check": "Exact vector re-run 3/3 on production -> INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE (chk-c1c0bd7e…, chk-d0cdb705…, chk-e61656d3…)",
        "time_to_fix": "0 h 44 min"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "NUMERIC_ADAPTER_BOUNDARY",
      "api_version": "V1",
      "state": "REPAIRED",
      "title": "Range-to-instance precision loss gave divergent verdicts for identical structures",
      "classification": "PUBLIC_ADAPTER_DEFECT (kernel exonerated)",
      "broken_at_utc": "2026-09-24T02:30:00Z",
      "reporter": null,
      "source": null,
      "todo": ["reporter and source not recorded"],
      "method": "Two payloads with the same structure (UNQUANTIFIED claim, INSTANCE RANGE evidence, PRIMARY_SOURCE): Astra [0.001, 0.01] returned INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE, BEST2 [0.0005, 0.02] returned SUPPORTED. The adapter rebuilt ranges via floating-point midpoint/uncertainty, narrowing the boundary.",
      "repro": {"job_ids": [], "observed": "INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE vs SUPPORTED", "expected": "same verdict for both", "evidence_ref": "blackbox/defects/NUMERIC_ADAPTER_BOUNDARY/"},
      "repair": {
        "repaired_at_utc": "2026-09-24T15:21:15Z",
        "fix_commit": "d9ee06a (Option C exact RANGE INSTANCE representation; preceded by 6f8bf1e at 2026-09-24T12:53:03Z)",
        "fix_summary": "ExactRangeObservedFact keeps the declared bounds exactly, with no ULP distortion. Full parity verified on 131 cases.",
        "regression_tests": ["tests/test_best2_contract_regression.py (added in 6f8bf1e)", "tests/test_adapter_exact_range_contract.py (added in d9ee06a)"],
        "released_in": "V1 public service (scoreboard: fixed_in OPTION_C_V04; engine 6f6aff4 unchanged)",
        "time_to_fix": "12 h 51 min (to Option C commit)"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "A1",
      "api_version": "V1",
      "state": "REPAIRED",
      "title": "Omitted authority_tier treated as highest authority",
      "classification": "Public schema defect (kernel unchanged)",
      "broken_at_utc": null,
      "reporter": "Claude (source-blind external adversarial campaign CLAUDE_BLIND_ADV_V01)",
      "source": "LLM",
      "todo": ["discovery date/time not found in repo"],
      "method": "Evidence items without authority_tier were accepted and behaved as highest authority, while malformed tier tokens were rejected with 422.",
      "repro": {"job_ids": [], "observed": "accepted, highest authority", "expected": "422 (fail closed)", "evidence_ref": "evidence/claude-blind-adversarial-v01/"},
      "repair": {
        "repaired_at_utc": "2026-09-25T02:56:51Z",
        "fix_commit": "aea8e46c3c6870ab54774a2bf926b07b08af3f71 (PR #2, merged 2026-09-25T03:05:31Z)",
        "fix_summary": "authority_tier required in blackbox/schemas.py; omission rejected with HTTP 422.",
        "regression_tests": ["tests/test_a1_authority_omission.py (24 tests per PROJECT_HISTORY.md)"],
        "released_in": "V1 public schema (frozen engine 6f6aff4 unchanged)",
        "time_to_fix": null
      }
    }
  ]
}
